Sourcing replacement capacity can be a worrying and time consuming exercise at the best of times, even when you have sufficient notice there is to be a parting of ways. In the nightmare scenario of an unexpected carrier exit, this is often a stressful and existential threat for an MGA.

When approaching a new carrier, being prepared and ready to address the hurdles is key. There are a number of areas of validation the capacity provider will consider when deciding whether to offer terms:

  • Are you truly niche and are you expert in this field?
  • Do you compliment the carriers existing business and have a strategic fit?
  • Is your product/offering one that fits within the carrier’s appetite and meets minimum scale requirements?
  • Data (quality and availability)
  • Does the carrier have any similar competing MGAs?
  • MGA culture and expertise in its chosen sector
  • History and track record of profitable performance
  • Adoption of a portfolio management process to manage the forward-looking underwriting profit

Building and maintaining relationships with insurers so both parties understand whether there is a natural fit is just the first step. However, the final two points in the list above are arguably the most important factors, yet are often the most overlooked and underprepared areas an MGA is faced with when engaging with a potential new carrier.

Simply put, portfolio management is a repeatable process of monitoring emerging results, implementing actions and assessing the impact of how these actions are earning through into the underwriting result – all at a granular level within the portfolio. It monitors both the forward-looking performance as well as a retrospective view. Quite often, it is the forward-looking view that is missing from an MGAs toolkit.

Whether you have a strong historic set of results or not, being able to clearly articulate the reasons for this, along with the steps taken and how these steps (with actuarial validation), are projected to earn through into the result to improve or maintain profitability are crucial in getting the buy-in from an insurer’s underwriting, pricing and finance teams. It is a confidence and competence test an insurer will make before deciding to entrust you with their capital. If you have a less that desirable track record, this becomes even more critical.

The benefits of this approach are twofold: Speed of engagement with a new carrier and giving the carrier what they need when it comes to matters of the actuarial sort.

At Calibrant, we specialise in portfolio management and capacity placement. If you are looking for support:

  • In the adoption and implementation of portfolio management discipline
  • Assistance with performance conversations with carriers
  • Finding replacement/additional capacity or just looking to establish new insurer relationships

Then please reach out to any of the team and we’d be delighted to help.

These are all essential components of the tool kit, which you could think of as a bit like keeping a ‘go-bag’ for when you are on the run. Having all of the right ingredients to hand for when the unexpected arises is key and often makes the difference between success and failure.

Other articles...

How turning data into meaningful insight can help you thrive in a softening market
The prospect (or reality) of a softening market has featured at most industry conferences I have attended this year, whether as a direct agenda item or during questions posed to a panel of peers.
But is it possible to protect the book and grow profitably while margins are being squeezed?

 

READ MORE
From reporting to steering: What great portfolio management really looks like for an MGA

Ask a dozen people in the insurance industry what is meant by ‘portfolio management’, and you’ll probably receive a dozen different responses. Dig a little deeper by asking whether they operate an effective portfolio management process, and what that looks like, and you’ll find a stark contrast in responses.

READ MORE
Lloyd’s Delegated Authority under the spotlight

Lloyd’s warns that delegation is a privilege, not a shortcut. See what Rachel Turk’s Q2 message means for MGAs and syndicates—and how to stay compliant.

READ MORE
Perfection is the enemy of progress

Insurers often struggle to extract value from bordereaux data, we advocate for a hybrid approach that balances speed, scalability, and practicality.

READ MORE
Rich pickings

It’s a funny old game! The cyclical nature of the insurance market means insurers benefit from MGAs during soft markets but often cut ties during hard markets. But shouldn’t insurers should identify and partner with well-managed MGAs to capitalise on the  market conditions in a hard market?

READ MORE
The Portfolio Calibrator

In this blog I explore our “Portfolio Calibrator”, a set of contractual clauses that, together, provide a Carrier with the ability to commit multi-year capacity to an MGA.

 

READ MORE
To err is human, to underwrite divine

There has been a lot of speculation recently around the use of AI in insurance and how this signals the death knell for Underwriters. Having mopped up the coffee that I spat out and checked my life insurance provisions, this got me to thinking. Surely not all underwriters? But if not, then who?

READ MORE
Efficient or effective?

The ineffable question of the “effs”.  What should a business aim for – and more specifically, for us, the underwriting function in an insurance business – efficient operations or effective decision making?

READ MORE
The boiling frog

We have all heard of the boiling frog syndrome which says: if a frog is put in boiling water, it will jump out to protect itself. However, if you place a frog in cold water and slowly turn up the heat, it won’t notice the subtle increase in temperature and be boiled alive.

READ MORE
Playing the game

Game theory aims to shed light on outcomes where multiple actors operate.  Dry academe often assumes “ceteris paribus” even in social sciences, but in the real world when we are trying to anticipate the outcomes of decisions one actor makes it is essential to consider the possible and likely responses of other actors…

READ MORE
An inspector calls

In various parts of our lives, we are examined and tested to grade our ability and knowledge, be that driving tests, ‘A’ levels, or piano exams.

And so it is with the insurance industry.  Boards and regulators are increasingly pushing for demonstrable oversight.  This is especially true in the field of Delegated Authority (DA)…

READ MORE
Stick to Your Knitting

Managing General Agents (MGAs) provide insurers a broad opportunity for profitable growth. Operating in niche sectors with lean efficient models and providing customers with products that they often find hard to come by in the mainstream.  All of this is wrapped up with the relevant expertise and providing insurers with access to markets that…

READ MORE
Why an MGA shouldn’t fear the hard market

As 2022 was drawing to a close, insurers across the UK were starting to look at their results, keeping their fingers, toes and everything else that they could, crossed in the hope that December would fizzle out in a whimper.

But alas it was not to be as temperatures plummeted and the industry suffered…

READ MORE
Actuarial big bucks

What use statisticians and actuaries when the world is being transformed by modern data-analysis techniques?  What hope for clunking humans in the era of Big Data (Facebook sells data which influences US presidential elections), of Artificial Intelligence (China can identify disliked racial groups through automatic facial recognition technology)…

READ MORE
Pricing triptych – Part 3: Four fallacies about cat pricing

Catastrophes – natural events where one “system” (wind, earthquake etc) causes multiple insurance claims in one go – are difficult.  Much else in insurance pricing is subject to conceptually simple averaging-over-time, but cats are different.  You can’t take a 5 or 10 year history of natural-peril losses and assume you have an accurate view of exposure to catastrophes…

READ MORE
Pricing triptych – Part 2: Four considerations on pricing strategy

In part 1 of this triptych on insurance pricing we looked at Technical Price (TP): what must be covered over the long run to make reasonable profits.  I finished that note by considering TP in the context of the market.  Here, I take this theme further and explore more how to think strategically about pricing.

READ MORE
Pricing triptych – Part 1: The four fundamentals of pricing

This note covers the fundamentals: the three building blocks of a technical price and a note on the role technical price plays.  It is followed with a deeper look at pricing strategies.  Finally we consider a knotty topic, cat(astrophe) pricing, in particular the use of cat models to inform the price.

READ MORE
In data we trust (so make sure it’s right)

On 26th September 1983, at the height of the Cold War, Soviet missile monitoring picked up apparent signs of five nuclear missiles launched from the US.  Retaliation was the default planned reaction.

READ MORE
Conflict: anticipating it, managing it

Charles Dickens opened A Tale of Two Cities with these lines, contrasting calm enlightenment London with turbulent revolutionary Paris: “It was the best of times, it was the worst of times…

READ MORE
Carrier vs MGA

Calibrant was established to bridge a gap.  The gap is that between MGAs and their carriers.  And it finds many forms.

READ MORE