How turning data into meaningful insight can help you thrive in a softening market

Of course, many MGAs and carrier/MGA relationships find ways to marry incentives with greater or lesser success. These include profit sharing mechanisms, transparent management information shared and interpreted consistently, binder contracts that respond to certain Key Performance Indicators, and simply a shared mindset and culture of what “good” looks like. These mechanisms can remove the sharp edges of crude rate strength by via product richness, sophisticated rate relativities, and strength of customer and broker relationships.
Be that as it may, the experience and reputation of the MGA model is not pristine. Many respectable insurers simply “don’t do” delegated authority business. Many others are wary as they dip their toe.
Delegated authority, however, has a very powerful case in its favour. By focusing on a narrow product range or customer segment (or means of distribution, for many insurtechs), the MGA brings a focus not possible in large insurers. This focus is a necessary condition for success wherever the insurance proposition doesn’t fit the operational or strategic model of an insurer. Non-core business, operational disruption, management distraction, absence of scale economies: these reasons mean many insurers can’t do what many MGAs do. But it’s still insurance, where successful pricing and underwriting married to successful operations and distribution can make money and deliver growth.
And this is why carriers should love the MGA model: bring what you do well (manage and aggregate risk for profit) to an insurance proposition that you find difficult to accommodate operationally.
Which brings us back to the gap, which can manifest itself in many ways. Sometimes it’s just simply not valuing the same data and MI. Or different success drivers. Or each side having very little awareness of how hard it is to execute the other’s responsibilities: a carrier may think it’s easy to distribute a niche product; an MGA may consider that the pricing is easy compared to customer service. If this gap between the MGA and the carrier can be bridged, the delegated authority model has brilliant opportunities for success for both of them. Calibrant’s objectives are to do this with a combination of relationship and contractual management, and actuarial and analytical insight. We have built our track record working for carriers and have learned some positive and negative lessons along the way. We will share more of our experience and thoughts in future entries in this section.