How turning data into meaningful insight can help you thrive in a softening market

But it doesn’t always go to plan which can be catastrophic, indeed existential, for the MGA. When results are (consistently) bad, insurers can lose faith and given they tend to have limited control, the safe option is for them to withdraw capacity. And the loss of capacity is usually the number one worry that keeps MGA bosses awake at night.
Of course, there can be a number of reasons why MGAs may lose capacity, some of which are outside of their control e.g. insurers retracting from or consolidating certain lines of business (just look at the emerging market results for 2022 and it is easy to understand why!) However, one common theme in all of this is usually linked to growth and diversification.
The owners of an MGA usually seek growth. But growth in a niche market is, by definition, tough.
Cutting rates to drive volume leads to an obvious problem down the line and the responsible, well managed MGA will avoid that route at all costs. So, we sometimes start to see MGAs broaden their offering into different products or blur the lines between mainstream and niche profiles in order to achieve their growth ambitions.
There are advantages to diversification. For example, a diversified company is potentially better insulated against a loss of profit/revenue in one business area and there are multiple examples where careful, measured diversification has worked. Amazon is a prime (no pun intended) example of this, moving from purely retailing books to the digitisation of these and the associated Kindle device from which to read these on, not to mention their “buy everything here” shopfront, cloud computing, and TV production.
Unfortunately, though, there are numerous examples of diversification gone wrong. AIG entered the credit security market, selling a form credit default insurance with a systemically-exposed value of $400bn at risk, and which led to the company failing after the 2008 financial crisis.
Or Blue Circle diversifying from cement into all things home related (bricks, bath-tubs, lawnmowers). One executive at Blue Circle stated that “our move into lawn mowers was based on the logic that you need a lawn mower for your garden—which, after all, is next to your house.” Association alone is not a good enough reason and is no surprise therefore that Blue Circle’s efforts failed.
MGAs want to grow and evolve, but expansion has got to be carefully thought through, measured and controlled. Before diversifying, consider:
But if you can’t tick all the requisite boxes, then maybe it is best to stick with what you know.